| Bowler |
Year |
Average |
Games |
League |
Comments |
| Carl Maudlin |
1916-1917 |
191 |
60 |
City |
|
| Bobby Overton |
1926-1927 |
191 |
75 |
City |
|
| Harry Schneiderman |
1926-1927 |
191 |
75 |
City |
|
| Harry Schneiderman |
1927-1928 |
193 |
|
City |
|
| Henry "Lefty" Willer |
1930-1931 |
199.3 |
103 |
City |
|
| Fred Hurstel |
1938-1939 |
199.68 |
|
City |
Recognized as the first 200 average |
| Eddie Schupp |
1946-1947 |
202.6 |
|
City |
Don Lowry had 201.63 and Hap Land 200.03 in the same league |
| Don Johnson |
1961-1962 |
209 |
|
Play Bowl Classic |
Ray Cameron averaged 206 in the Continental League in 1961 |
| Carl Babb |
1963-1964 |
209 tie |
|
Play Bowl Classic |
|
| Steve Preston |
1978-1979 |
217 |
|
|
|
| Steve Preston |
1979-1980 |
218 |
|
|
|
| Steve Preston |
1980-1981 |
220 |
93 |
Miracle Shield |
|
| Brian Graham |
1995-1996 |
221 |
78 |
Progressive |
|
| Clint Spencer |
1997-1998 |
222 |
96 |
Kokomo Sports Center Classic |
|
| Jon Kelley |
1998-1999 |
227 |
132 |
Kokomo Sports Center Classic |
|
| Jon Kelley |
1999-2000 |
228 |
90 |
Kokomo Sports Center Classic |
|
| Matt Duncan |
2004-2005 |
228 tie |
99 |
Sunday Night Mixed Late |
|
| Jon Kelley |
2007-2008 |
230 |
81 |
Wednesday Night Classic |
|
| Trent Marner |
2022-2023 |
233 |
90 |
Dash For Cash |
|
| Eric Matthews |
2024-2025 |
234 |
84 |
Dash for Cash |
|
